A: the other two are from the same island.
But A is a liar. This means that AT LEAST ONE (NOT NECESSARILY BOTH) of the others (B, C) are not from the same island as A. That's the truth.
B: the other two are from the same island.
But B is a liar. This means that AT LEAST ONE (NOT NECESSARILY BOTH) of the others (A, C) are not from the same island as B. That's the truth.
C: Both of them are not from the same island.
C always tells the truth, and he told the truth.
This isn't a good variation of the truth teller/liar puzzle. A valid answer to this puzzle demonstrates the puzzle has a hole. If all three islanders are from the truth telling island their answers would all be the same and the puzzle would be trivial.
The puzzle should include an additional condition, which stipulates that the three islanders are not all from the same island so that the answer REQUIRES a logical explanation.
In c the answer should have been the other two are from the same island. That could be true, because he tells the truth. Right? A and B, should be of the same island because both of them are liars. GEt the point?
There are either two liars and a truthteller, or three truthtellers. In any case, the third islander will say the two others are from the same island, so the answer is correct.
B: liar
C: truthteller
A: the other two are from the same island.
But A is a liar. This means that AT LEAST ONE (NOT NECESSARILY BOTH) of the others (B, C) are not from the same island as A. That's the truth.
B: the other two are from the same island.
But B is a liar. This means that AT LEAST ONE (NOT NECESSARILY BOTH) of the others (A, C) are not from the same island as B. That's the truth.
C: Both of them are not from the same island.
C always tells the truth, and he told the truth.
pwnt ;)
The puzzle should include an additional condition, which stipulates that the three islanders are not all from the same island so that the answer REQUIRES a logical explanation.